Year School
2026  Marian
2025 Marian
2024 Marian
2023 Marian
2022 Marian
2021 Marian
2019 Indiana Wesleyan
2018  Taylor
2017 Marian
2016 Indiana Wesleyan
2015 Indiana Wesleyan
2014 Indiana Wesleyan
2013  Taylor
2012 Indiana Wesleyan
2011 Bethel
2010 Bethel
2009 Bethel
2008 Bethel
2007 Indiana Wesleyan
2006 Bethel